Originally Posted by: irishsnoutBut I guess better to post with mistakes and get critisizm. I'll try to pick more with the wrist.
I just want to be really clear, I'm not talking about the mistakes... those were fine... you played really cleanly and couple of little errors are no big deal.
I'm talking specifically about moving your thumb to pick the string, as opposed to keeping your thumb locked and using your wrist to make the pick go up and down. Its not a "criticism" in that it would be "better" if you played differently.
Its an observation and
you are going to hurt yourself if you don't stop. There is good news... you're new, it will be easy to change, and I can tell from your video that you have HUGE potential... you're going to be a good guitar player! Your left hand (fretting hand) is fantastic for a beginner.. the way you can make your fingers hover over the strings, including your pinky... that's not easy for everyone to do. Some people take years to be able to play like that, some people just can't keep their pinky in "hover mode" the way you do no matter how hard they try. You're going to improve very quickly.
But you are going to lose it all to carpal tunnel syndrome if you don't change your picking technique.Sorry for the stupid bold mellow drama, but you need to stop playing like that, and stop now. If you get carpal tunnel, it may end your guitar playing for good.
The tendons connecting your thumb were just not designed to take that kind of repetitive motion. I could tell right away that you were likely losing the pick every now and then. And I can tell you are going to develop repetitive-motion-injuries that are going to force you to stop playing.
Here's what I'd love for you to do... find a reputable guitar teacher out there... someone you feel you can trust. Tell them you'd like to take a 1 hour lesson and that you have this weird picking style that you need to correct.
Go to the lesson and work only on your picking technique. Make sure its starting to feel right while you're there with the instructor and work on nothing else until you are picking normally. Resist the impulse to work on other stuff and say "I'll get the picking sorted out later". You need to sort it out now. You need to stop playing until you do, or you will be forced to stop.
I know this seems like over-the-top mellow drama, and you may be rolling your eyes thinking "who is this guy?!"... but I can't emphasize enough how your guitar playing is going to come to a sudden halt. Your thumb will get sore. The soreness will spread up your forearm. Keep playing and you will get numbness, tingling and pain with movement of your thumb. Eventually it will also get very weak, and you'll no longer be able to play. Recovery will include changing your technique, and its not unheard of to require a year of no playing before you heal up enough to be able to start again.
Its not at all your fault. Obviously, you never had someone show you how to pick properly and you just developed an unusual method. It happens. I knew a girl that played acoustic and played with nothing but downstrokes... really weird but it was just the way she did it.
Anyways, go get a lesson... don't wait... I know you want to keep progressing. Don't "try" to pick differently... DO IT or trust me, you're going to end up having to stop. For you and anyone reading this, this is nothing to be embarrassed about... you're not getting "called out" or anything like that... its not your fault at all, but you do need to change before an injury forces the issue for you.